Lemonade vs. Root: Which Insurance Stock is a Better Choice?

: LMND | Lemonade Inc. News, Ratings, and Charts

LMND – Today I’ll analyze Lemonade (LMND) and Root (ROOT) to determine which insurance stock is a better buy.

Insurance companies are financial intermediaries that offer direct insurance or reinsurance services, taking on risks in return for the payment of premiums. The difference between premiums and claims is the revenue of insurers. In addition, insurance companies invest their assets in low-risk securities such as U.S. bonds, which makes them sensitive to FED’s interest rate. 

According to Research and Markets, the global insurance industry is expected to reach $6,390.73 billion by 2025, growing at a CAGR of 6% between 2021 and 2025. The increasing risk awareness, rising demand for protection, and rate hardening in non-life insurance commercial lines should drive the industry’s growth during the forecast period. 

With this in mind, I am going to analyze and compare two insurance stocks, Lemonade, Inc. (LMND) and Root, Inc. (ROOT), to determine which one is currently a better investment. 

Founded in 2015, Lemonade offers different insurance options for clients in the US and Europe. Lemonade insurance products cover stolen or damaged property, personal liability, and it has a variety of other insurance policies. Based in Columbus, Ohio, Root provides auto, homeowners, and renters insurance products through its mobile application and website.

Year-to-Date (YTD), LMND stock has fallen about 50%, while shares of ROOT dropped 47.5% over the same period.

Recent Developments 

On February 8th, Lemonade announced that it had expanded its pet insurance option to Massachusetts. The company said that it is the 37th state where it provides the coverage. Earlier in February, Metromile stockholders approved a previously proposed all-stock merger with Lemonade. The deal should be completed during the second quarter of 2022. Consequently, this acquisition is estimated to bring long-term benefits for Lemonade.

On January 26th, Root announced the completion of a new $300 million loan facility with BlackRock. The 5-year term loan will have an interest rate that equals SOFR + 9%. Management believes that this loan will strengthen Root’s liquidity position and extend its debt maturity. 

Recent Quarterly Performance & Analysts’ Estimates

On February 23rd, Lemonade issued its earnings results for the fourth quarter of 2021, causing its shares to fall over 20% on an EPS miss and a weak outlook. In Q4, Lemonade’s revenue increased 100% year-over-year to $41 million, topping the Wall Street revenue consensus by $1.6 million. Strong revenue growth was driven by an increase of gross earned premium and increases in net investment income & commission income. However, the company reported GAAP EPS of ($1.14), missing analysts estimates by $0.01.

It is also important to note that its In Force Premium (IFP), which calculates as the aggregate annualized premium for customers as of the period end date, was up 78% year-over-year to $380 million. The number of customers stood 43% higher year-over-year at 1,427,481. Finally, the premium per customer came in at $266 in Q4, representing a 25% year-over-year increase. 

A ($1.28) consensus EPS estimate for the first fiscal quarter, ending March 31st, 2021, indicates a 58.02% year-over-year decrease. However, analysts expect Lemonade’s revenue to increase 86.98% year-over-year to $43.94 million in the current quarter.

Root’s total revenue for its fiscal fourth quarter, ended December 31st, 2021, grew 83.1% year-over-year to $93.2 million. The revenue growth was mainly related to a 92.5% YoY increase in net earned premium to $84.9 million, driven by a decrease in cession rate and growth in gross earned premium compared to a year-ago quarter. Also, Root topped the Wall Street consensus revenue projections by $31.34 million. The company reported a GAAP EPS of ($0.44), missing Wall Street estimates by $0.06.

For the first quarter, analysts expect ROOT’s EPS to stand at ($0.42), down 4.57% on a year-over-year basis. Besides, analysts forecast that its current-quarter revenue should be $76.78 million, showing a moderate YoY growth of 11.92%.

Comparing Options Market Sentiment

Looking at the March 18th, 2022, option chain for both LMND and ROOT, we can define options market sentiment by analyzing the calls/puts ratio. In LMND’s case, the open calls/open puts ratio at the $23.00 strike price comes in at 0.57x, implying a bearish options market sentiment. When it comes to ROOT, the open calls/open puts ratio at the $2.50 strike price is 10.13x, showing a heavy bullish market sentiment.  

Conclusion

While Lemonade and Root should benefit from the insurance market’s growth in the long term, I believe Root appears to be a better investment at current levels based on its higher-than-anticipated financials, favorable growth prospects, and superior options market sentiment.


LMND shares were trading at $20.94 per share on Thursday morning, down $1.36 (-6.10%). Year-to-date, LMND has declined -50.27%, versus a -8.06% rise in the benchmark S&P 500 index during the same period.


About the Author: Oleksandr Pylypenko


Oleksandr Pylypenko has more than 5 years of experience as an investment analyst and financial journalist. He has previously been a contributing writer for Seeking Alpha, Talks Market, and Market Realist. More...


More Resources for the Stocks in this Article

TickerPOWR RatingIndustry RankRank in Industry
LMNDGet RatingGet RatingGet Rating
ROOTGet RatingGet RatingGet Rating

Most Popular Stories on StockNews.com


Inflation Not Fading Fast Enough for Stock Investors

Investors may have celebrated the end of high inflation too soon. The CPI report shows inflation bouncing higher and thus pushing back the start date for Fed rate cuts. This has the S&P 500 (SPY) coming off recent highs. This begs questions like how much more downside could we see? And when will the bull market get back on track? 44 year investment veteran Steve Reitmeister shares his answers to these questions in this timely commentary including a preview of his top picks to stay ahead of the pack. Read on below for more...

3 Auto Stocks to Consider Over TSLA in April

Tesla (TSLA) reported a decline in deliveries in the first quarter, and Wall Street expects the company to deliver fewer vehicles than last year. Furthermore, rising competition, slowing EV sales, and stretched valuation make TSLA unattractive from an investment standpoint. Considering these factors, investors could consider buying fundamentally strong auto stocks Blue Bird (BLBD), Rolls-Royce Holdings (RYCEY), and Stellantis (STLA) over Tesla (TSLA). Read more...

3 Top-Rated Tech Stock Buys for Value in April

The technology sector is undergoing a notable surge, propelled by increasing digitalization endeavors among businesses and governmental support for technological progress. So, fundamentally sound tech stocks Box Inc. (BOX), Teradata (TDC), and Materialise (MTLS), which seem pretty undervalued, might be ideal buys this month. Continue reading...

Top Software Stocks at the Forefront of Market Gains

The software industry's prospects appear bright due to increasing investments in digital transformation, high demand for advanced software services from various sectors, and the integration of emerging technologies such as generative AI. Therefore, investors could consider buying quality software stocks Autodesk (ADSK), DocuSign (DOCU), and Pegasystems (PEGA) for solid gains. Read more...

Updated 2024 Stock Market Outlook

The bull market continues to rage on with the S&P 500 (SPY) making new highs. That is the past...the question is what does the future hold? That is why 44 year investment veteran Steve Reitmeister provides this updated 2024 Stock Market Outlook to help you carve a path to outperformance the rest of the year. Read on below for the full story...

Read More Stories

More Lemonade Inc. (LMND) News View All

Event/Date Symbol News Detail Start Price End Price Change POWR Rating
Loading, please wait...
View All LMND News